MANCHESTER RESTAURANT REVIEWS - James Martin Manchester Reviews  
Restaurants Of Manchester
James Martin Manchester

James Martin Manchester Reviews
AddressManchester 235, The Great Northern, Watson Street, Manchester, M3 4LP
Book onlineBOOK ONLINE  Phone0161 820 1941

"The Yorkshire Dales in the heart of Manchester city centre"
James Martin Manchester Review
James Martin Manchester Review
Restaurants Of Manchester (Monday 28th October 2019)

Key: 5 stars = World Class!   4 stars = FANTASTIC   3 stars = GOOD   2 stars = OK   1 star = Poor

Decor & Ambience Very Good
Don’t be put off by having to enter James Martin's Manchester restaurant through a casino - unless you are under 18, of course - as the venue itself, is set well away from the gambling area at the top of a sweeping staircase. 

It is inviting and attractive, embracing the 1899 industrial chic of the Great Northern Warehouse, in which it is housed; a large open dining room with bare brick walls, subtle mood lighting, booth seating and round tables draped in white table cloths.

A private dining room sits behind frosted glass, whilst an adjacent window looks into the “Meat Market” fridge, where huge cuts of meat hang on display.

As mentioned, you need to be over 18 to enter.

The furniture hasn’t changed over the years, however its antique appearance complements the late 19th Century surroundings.

James Martin Manchester Review
Food & Drink Very Good
Good honest cooking is James Martin’s trademark and the food served at Manchester 235 epitomises that.

Top quality ingredients, like the Cumbrian Lakeland Fells beef, Yorkshire Wagyu and Herdwick lamb - all ageing on display in the Meat Market window - are treated with the care and attention they deserve by fellow Yorkshireman, Doug Crampton, who has headed the kitchen here since it opened in 2013.

With new competitors in the city raising the culinary bar, James Martin Manchester have also had to step up their game, and, on this showing, have done so noticeably.

From starters to dessert; the complimentary sourdough with beef dripping (incredible), through to the excellent Hot Sticky Toffee Pudding (£7), each dish was cooked well and there was enough "wow" moments, leaving us impressed.

Whilst the emphasis is on quality meats, a large vegan and vegetarian menu covers all bases - just ask to be seated away from the “Meat Market” window though if dead animal carcasses put you off.

We are glad to report that our only disappointment during the whole meal was with the Steamed Wagyu Ox Cheek Pudding (£9.50); and, even then, it was an annoyance that the starter dish was so stunningly tasty, a larger portion was required - they really should offer it as a main course dish.

I have since sang its praises to various chefs around town, who are all now planning trips just to experience this one dish alone - Put simply; you’ll never eat Steak & Kidney Pudding again without reminiscing about this dish.

James Martin Manchester Review James Martin Manchester Review
Steamed Wagyu ox cheek pudding (£9.50) Sea bream ceviche (£9.50)
Price OK/Good
There are some incredible deals to be had at James Martin, including a 5 Course Tasting Menu for just £30, and only £17.50 for matching wines (or £23.50 for Premium wines) - arguably the best deal to be had in Manchester!

One of the best Sunday Roasts in Manchester only costs £15 whilst, a la carte wise, there is enough here to suit every budget, with main courses from £15 (Smoked Heritage Carrot), right through to a huge sharing platter of Roast rib of Cumbrian beef, malt glazed Wagyu ox cheek, and beef ragu with sourdough crumb (£70), or 10oz Sirloin Yorkshire Wagyu for £44.
Away from the wine pairing option, bottles aren’t cheap - the South African house MiIlstream Chenin Blanc (£23) is a Carlsberg distributed label that can be found in many of their pubs for a tenner less. Most of the other bins on the menu are also priced £10-£15 less elsewhere, whilst the markup on the Fine Wines is even more noticeable, unless you've just won big on the Roulette. For example, a bottle of the excellent Barossa Valley blend, The Holy Trinity, will set you back £79; a whopping £60 more than it costs in the shops.
James Martin Manchester Review James Martin Manchester Review
Herdwick lamb rump (£23) Brown butter poached brill (£23)
Service Fantastic/World Class

On this particular evening, service had improved massively from our last three visits, and our main waiter (a young lad from Bury) was completely on the ball; friendly, knowledgeable, chatty and efficient.

Having come to James Martin from The Ivy, his professionalism and attention to detail was as good as any we have experienced in even the finest of fine dining restaurants.

We visited early doors on a quiet Monday evening, so it would be interesting to see if the high standards can be maintained during busier periods and by the rest of the service team. From what we witnessed, we would be surprised if not.

James Martin Manchester Review James Martin Manchester Review
Hot sticky toffee pudding (£7) Mango souffle (£7)
Overall Very Good
Eating inside a casino might be some people’s idea of Food Hell, although it needn’t be, unless you have youngsters in your party. Once past the seemingly intimidating front desk membership questions, and through the gaming floor, the restaurant is set far enough away from the gamblers for you to even notice.

As mentioned, the wines, although decent, are considerably more expensive than the less fancy pubs and restaurants in which you’ll normally find them - go for a wine pairing instead if you’re looking for better value for money.

Whilst James Martin’s name is on the door and his celebrated style obvious within the recipes, on this showing at least, Doug Crampton’s cooking is certainly worthy of a Michelin Plate and an AA Rosette or two; which it would no doubt boast, if the restaurant was located in the middle of the Yorkshire Dales, rather than inside Manchester’s plushest casino.
It’s a destination restaurant inside the city centre - with free parking - and, with such good promotions to be found, and a diverse menu, you’ll probably find your Food Heaven here. ~ Restaurants Of Manchester (28th October 2019)

Book onlineBOOK ONLINE

"James Martin don’t scrimp on produce quality one bit"
James Martin Manchester Review James Martin Manchester Review
James Martin Manchester Review

Restaurants Of Manchester (Tuesday 5th February 2019)

Key: 5 stars = World Class!   4 stars = Fantastic   3 stars = GOOD   2 stars = OK   1 star = Poor

Decor & Ambience 4 stars

Despite being located in the heart of Manchester's biggest casino, James Martin does a great job of making you forget that you're, well, in the heart of Manchester's biggest casino. It feels like a bona fide restaurant, separate from the wider business, with no clatter of chips to be heard. At least not the plastic variety. 

The steps leading up to the dining space give a real sense of anticipation on approach, and it's broadly a smart dining space with eye-catching lighting and a truly warm feel.  Other customers were having a great time and there was a real buzz about the place, even on a wet Tuesday evening. If you're there as a couple, pre-ask for a window seat if you want to feel super cozy and out of the way.  In a group, ask for a booth. Inside tips!

We were there as a pair, and didn’t ask for a window seat, so sat on the other side of the aisle from the window seats, en route to/from the kitchen.  Pretty much every plate leaving said kitchen passed our table.  It felt like we were sat in an aisle seat on a rush hour train, not in a relaxing dining space.

The room feels in need of a little facelift after several solid years of wearing the same outfit.  It's a good looking place, but is just starting to show its age a little bit, especially when you visit a couple of times a year as we do.  Our table cloth was also a little dishevelled in places.  Details.
James Martin Manchester Review James Martin Manchester Review
Mushroom Consommé Bread & Butter
Price Fantastic

It's been a while since we've seen such stark contrasts in value at the same restaurant, on the same visit. The 5 course tasting menu, plus bread, is a mere £30, which without question places it as one of the best value tasting menus anywhere in the city.  As an added perk our wine pairing which is usually £15, was free via a promotion which runs during Jan and Feb.  This shifts the value for money level on the tasting menu and matched wines into the bonkers category. 

Value on the regular a la carte menu is also very decent too, considering the quality of produce being used, with 3 courses being doable for around £30. Some of the more expensive bottles on the wine list represent great value, notably the Jadot Muersault Narvaux at £85, which retails for around £50.

There's an awful lot of extremely high mark ups on the wine list.  The cheapest bottle available; Lobo Loco Tempranillo at £22 is a very average drop that’s available in some less than glam bars about town for 10 quid.  You can get it wholesale for around a fiver, so upwards of a 400% mark-up is silly. The story is the same with many of the cheaper and mid-range options.  Pick wisely.
James Martin Manchester Review James Martin Manchester Review
Thai Crab Risotto Smoked haddock 'Rarebit'
Service Fantastic

Everybody was pleasant, and said the right things more often than not.  The young man who appeared to be the junior server was actually the one who did the best job of any of the 4 people who tended to us.  He clearly cared, and his slight nervousness and self-doubt came across as passion and conscientiousness.  I couldn’t have done his job at his age, and you can't argue with that.

Whilst everybody ticked the boxes, generally, there was a massive feeling of them being on-script and forced, along with a slightly flat feel to things. Just over 2.5 hours for 5 tasting size courses felt slow.  Very slow.  We had to jog out of the building, which will do us some good in fairness.  Our last bus back out to the sticks is at 21:15, so had it been a £40 taxi home, the evening's value for money would have taken a right battering.

James Martin Manchester Review James Martin Manchester Review
Indian Spiced Chicken Blood Orange Eclair
Food & Drink 4 stars

James Martin don’t scrimp on produce quality one bit.  Yorkshire Wagyu beef is on the menu, we assume from the fantastic Warrendale Wagyu? Such delights are a sign that you're in a place which considers both region and quality.  And I guess that Yorkshire produce had to feature on any JM menu.

Via the tasting menu, we started with Mushroom Consommé which was finished with a meaty slice of hen of the woods.  This one split the table, but I personally found great pleasure at the bottom of my stoneware bowl.  Lovely earthiness and bags of umami in the broth, with an acid burst from specks of raw, super-fine-diced onion. 

Some nice sourdough and lovely butter with balsamic/OO dip comprised the second course. 

Thai Crab Risotto followed, which, as much as the Italian purist in me hates saying it; was rather splendid.  Getting the flavour balance on this one would be a feat, but they did it. 

The course of the night, we all agreed.  Smoked haddock 'rarebit' was next off the pass, and whoever said that fish doesn’t mix with cheese, was wrong.  The fish was cooked like a dream and flaked away ideally.  The cheese may have been a bit big in flavour for the delicate fish, but I didn’t mind that personally.  Garnish was a Scotch style egg, which looked great on the plate.  The whole dish was lifted by some lovely curry emulsion, or mayo, to you and I. 

The main course of Indian Spiced Chicken was an aromatic affair, with no heat from the spice crust, but bags of textbook Indian scent.  It was dressed with a couple of potato nuggets, leaf, some spinach yoghurt, and a chicken jus based sauce. 

The cheese board which we ended on was again well done, in both quality and variety.

A few little cooking errors, including some undercooked egg white, gone-astray crab cartilage in the risotto, flavour lacking scotch egg, some soggy chicken skin, and an under-par pudding course, all marred things somewhat, which was frustrating as the quality of cooking was broadly very decent. 

The latter dish, the one that you often remember the most, suffered from burnt/crispy choux pastry, filled with over-whipped cream, topped with another overdone and hence bitter after-tasting biscuit/tuile. The admittedly lovely sorbet, which being acidic and tart by nature, badly needed the other components to be contrastingly sweet, rather than also bitter, to give that all important balance.

James Martin Manchester Review James Martin Manchester Review
Cheese Board Entrance to James Martin Manchester
Overall Very Good

As much as it was polite and friendly, service felt scripted and was slow.  A few minor food niggles, and watch those wine mark-ups on the cheaper bottles too.

There's a clear use of great produce, some solid cooking, and generally high standards across the food board, with quality and prices which ideally relate.  It's got good presence, just the right level of glamour, and the dining room is still a lovely place after all these years.  You'll be hard pressed to find a better casino restaurant, and it will appeal to the vast majority of customers' tastes and wallets. ~ Restaurants Of Manchester (5th February 2019)

Book onlineBOOK ONLINE


Disclaimer: and can not be held responsible for any differences experienced at the premises listed.

All images and information © 2002-2019 Pride Of Manchester


Best Bars in Europe
Best Restaurants in Europe
Best Hotels in Europe
UK Theatre Guides
London Theatres
Manchester Theatres
Edinburgh Theatres
Liverpool Theatres
Birmingham Theatres

Amsterdam Bars & Restaurants
Barcelona Bars & Restaurants
Berlin Bars & Restaurants
Bratislava Bars & Restaurants
Copenhagen Bars & Restaurants
Gothenburg Bars & Restaurants
Helsinki Bars & Restaurants
Krakow Bars & Restaurants
Lisbon Bars & Restaurants
London Bars & Restaurants
Madrid Bars & Restaurants
Milan Bars & Restaurants
Rome Bars & Restaurants
Vienna Bars & Restaurants
Zurich Bars & Restaurants
~ other cities in Europe ~